Meniscal Injuries

By StevenM. Crenshaw, MD

Meniscal Injuries

Meniscal injuries represent one of the most common problems seen by the orthopaedic surgeon evaluating knee conditions. It is the most common knee problem treated surgically. While its presentation varies in different age groups, it is a problem seen throughout adulthood. Problems occur in athletes and non athletes alike. Technology advances have improved our ability to diagnose and treat various meniscal problems, and have succeeded in restoring knee function to many individuals.

Knee Anatomy

First in the discussion of meniscal injuries is to understand normal meniscal anatomy and function. The knee is a hinged joint that flexes, extends, and rotates slightly. The upper half of the joint has a curved surface whereas the lower half is flat resulting in some degree of mismatch between the two. The meniscus is a semicircular disc of cartilage that is attached to the tibia and joint capsule. Its central portion thins down to an edge resulting in improved conformity between the curved and flat surfaces of the joint.

Types of meniscus tear

Meniscus injuries


There is a single meniscus in the inner and outer compartments of the knee. The functions of the meniscus are multiple and include improvement in the conformity of joint surfaces, shock absorption to impact loads across the joint, stability to abnormal movements of the knee, maintaining healthy cartilage through joint fluid lubrication, and sensory feed back to joint motion.

The blood supply is an important and unique consideration as only the outer third of the meniscus has blood vessels within it whereas the inner two thirds does not. Thus, the ability for meniscal tears to heal are in tears involving the inner two thirds versus the outer third tears. Degenerative changes due to age make it more susceptible to tears. Meniscal tears can be acute, chronic, or a combination of the two.

Acute Meniscus Tears

Acute tears tend to happen in younger individuals as a result of a forced twisting and loading injury to the knee and may be associated with other ligamentous, cartilage, or bone injuries. These tears may occur in the vascularized portion of the meniscus and heal or can be successfully repaired. Chronic tears tend to involve the central portion of the meniscus, frequently result in a more complex tear pattern and rarely heal. Acute tears tend to occur more often in younger individuals during sporting or athletic events, whereas chronic tears may develop insidiously and occur more frequently in adults over forty.

Mechanism Of Injury

Diagnosing a meniscal tear starts with a history of how the injury occurred and a thorough knee exam. Contact sports and those that involve twisting and jumping raise the suspicion of a tear, although, a specific injury may, in chronic cases be absent. Symptoms commonly will consist of sudden onset of knee pain, swelling, and catching type symptoms both with knee
movement and twisting of the knee. Occasionally, the knee may be locked in a position where it cannot be straightened or flexed due to interference of the torn meniscus.

Chronic Tears

Chronic tears may only present with localized pain, with or without swelling, or mechanical symptoms. Physical exam is most notable for swelling, isolated tenderness over the joint line, and pain with twisting movements of the knee. Associated injuries including those to the cruciate or collateral ligaments should also be assessed.


X-rays are important for eliminating other conditions such as arthritis or developmental knee problems involving the cartilage or bone. An arthrogram is an x-ray with injection of dye into the joint.  It was the standard test prior to using the MRI.


The MRI is the diagnostic tool which physicians order to evaluate the meniscus.  An MRI with contrast can enhance the clarity by injecting dye into the knee joint. An MRI scan is not absolutely necessary to make the diagnosis of a meniscus tear as this may be clinically obvious. MRI scans can further be confusing as they may show degenerative changes within the meniscus which can cause an improper diagnosis of a tear.

Knee Arthroscopy

Knee arthroscopy is seen as the absolute standard for evaluating the meniscus if suspicion of a tear is high.
Treatments of meniscal injuries continue to evolve with time. Prior to the advent of arthroscopy, most symptomatic tears treatment were through a surgical incision and removing of the entire meniscus. In part, as a result of this treatment, many individuals result was premature arthritis. This procedure no longer an option, except in extreme circumstances.

ACL Ligaments

Ligaments and Meniscus of the Knee

Conservative Treatment of Meniscal Tears

Surgical treatment is not appropriate for all meniscal tears as some may either be insignificant or able to heal without intervention. These include stable tears in the vascularized portion of the outer meniscus or small tears isolated to the inner meniscus. Conservative treatment includes a period of rest to allow pain and swelling to resolve, use of anti-inflammatory medications, and physical therapy directed at restoring strength, mobility, and function.

Return to Function

Progressive return to preinjury activities is a primary goal and can be successful. Surgical treatment for meniscus injuries is appropriate for tears which are unstable.  As well as for those which do not  improve with conservative treatment. Arthroscopic surgery allows the orthopaedic surgeon to both evaluate the meniscus and perform treatment. Surgical treatment depends on the type of tear present and its location.

Chronic or degenerative tears treatment is usually a partial meniscectomy.  This removes of the torn tissue while retaining the remainder of the meniscus. Acute tears occurring in the portion of the inner meniscus are also an indication for partial resection. Meniscal repair techniques consist of various means to reattach the torn meniscus.  Also to stimulate it to heal and are appropriate for tears in the vascularized portion of the meniscus.

Other Ligaments

It is also important to address other conditions such as torn ligaments and alignment problems that may adversely affect meniscal healing. The recovery following surgery to the meniscus varies depending upon the procedure.  However, in general all attempts are made to restore knee motion, strength, and function as early as possible.


In general, results of meniscal treatments are very successful. Following partial meniscectomy, most individuals can resume their preinjury activities. Long term results following partial meniscectomy and meniscal repair have not shown the degree of deterioration of the joint that was previously noted following removal of the entire meniscus.

While osteoarthritis frequently accompanies degenerative tears of the meniscus, it may not be as symptomatic.  The meniscus tear itself and appropriate treatment allows some individuals the ability to resume their previous lifestyle.


Individuals who have knee pain symptoms which not fully explained either by arthritis or other known injuries should seek evaluation for meniscal injuries. Almost all orthopaedic surgeons who see and treat knee disorders train with these various techniques.  MD’s can diagnose and treat your disease as well as assist these individuals in their treatment and recovery.

Related Articles:

meniscal tear

lateral meniscus tear

types of meniscus tears

To schedule an appointment for physical therapy at one of the 12 JOI Rehab Centers, please call 904-858-7045.

In conclusion, if you need to schedule with a JOI Orthopedic Knee Doctor, please call 904-JOI-2000 for an appointment.

Where The Pros Go

Where The Pro’s Go

Skip to content